Why Every Nonprofit Board Should Conduct an Annual Self-Assessment

  • Your nonprofit is better positioned to fulfill its mission, maintain donor trust
  • A board self-assessment is an often-overlooked but invaluable way to strengthen board governance
  • Unpacks why a board self-assessment should form part of your toolkit
  • Shares strategies for conducting an effective assessment, plus sample questions to get started
  • Why Your Nonprofit Board Should Conduct a Self-Assessment Nonprofit leaders are often juggling fundraising goals, organizational challenges
  • That leaves little room for much else
  • Instead of viewing a self- assessment as another administrative
Written by: David Rhode | Reviewed by: Vicki Burkhart
Why Every Nonprofit Board Should Conduct an Annual Self-Assessment
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
❤ Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
Add us as a preferred source on Google

Your nonprofit is better positioned to fulfill its mission, maintain donor trust, and ensure sustainability with an effective board in place. And a board self-assessment is an often-overlooked but invaluable way to strengthen board governance.

Below, I’ll unpack why a board self-assessment should form part of your toolkit. I’ll also share strategies for conducting an effective assessment, plus sample questions to get started.


Why Your Nonprofit Board Should Conduct a Self-Assessment

Nonprofit leaders are often juggling fundraising goals, organizational challenges, financial oversight, and other strategic priorities. That leaves little room for much else.

David Rhode Quote: "A self-assessment may seem uncomfortable (or like another task added to a never-ending list of priorities). But when conducted thoughtfully, it can be a powerful and productive way to identify opportunities for improvement and empower your board."

Instead of viewing a self-assessment as another administrative task, see it as an opportunity for healthy governance, trust-building, and engagement.

Tune in to this episode of the Nonprofit Podcast, where Brittan Stockert and I discuss what a board self-assessment covers, how it’s structured, and why it’s so important. 

Here’s more about how a self-assessment can benefit your board.


1. It encourages honest reflection

Many challenges faced as a board are often left unspoken. A board self-assessment encourages members to take a step back and voice their opinions across key areas.

Self-assessments provide a structured framework for evaluating the effectiveness of meetings, roles and responsibilities, leadership, skills utilization, and fundraising.

When members have a constructive way to share honest feedback and identify potential areas that require attention, it helps address problems before they become major issues.


2. It increases board engagement

Self-assessments let your board know you take their feedback seriously. And when members feel valued, they’ll ultimately invest more time and effort into the success of your mission.

By asking and responding to challenging questions and showing a commitment to continuous improvement, you’ll inspire greater engagement among board members.


3. It helps clarify board expectations

Oftentimes, we don’t set clear expectations when onboarding new members, which can result in a lack of clarity regarding roles and responsibilities.

Members should ideally learn about your organization, expectations from the board, and overall goals before joining the board. However, self-assessments help you understand their perspective and rectify any misconceptions head-on.

Clear expectations around meeting attendance, financial oversight, fundraising, and other crucial areas are easier to address when they form part of a broader anonymous evaluation.


4. It strengthens the relationship between board and staff members

When expectations are unclear, communication breaks down. This leads to a disconnect and tension between your board and staff members.

Regular self-assessments progressively build trust as challenges are voiced and addressed, strengthening alignment and relationships over time.

Demonstrating an ongoing commitment to self-improvement builds collaboration while creating a sense of partnership and mutual respect.


How to Conduct an Effective Board Self-Assessment

With a proper process in place, conducting a board self-assessment is less intimidating or daunting than it may seem.

It’s important to note that self-assessments do not necessarily have to fall on the shoulders of the Executive Director alone.

David Rhode Quote: "In my experience, I’ve found that many organizations utilize a Board Governance Committee to manage self-assessments. However, this may also be an opportunity to engage an external consultant, should your organization require additional support."

With this in mind, here are the steps to conducting a productive board self-assessment:

  1. Make it a discussion point at your next meeting: Notify board members that it’s best practice for boards to have a self-assessment, and lead the discussion. Let them know that it will be anonymous to encourage honest feedback.
  2. Decide who will conduct the assessment: Typically, self-assessments are facilitated by your nonprofit’s Executive Director, Board President, or Board Chief of Operations. Share the responsibility if you can, or work with a consultant.
  3. Compile a list of survey questions for the assessment: Work with your board members to create a first draft of questions. Include a mix of open-ended and closed-ended questions with a ”strongly agree” to “strongly disagree” scale for high-value feedback.
  4. Share the initial self-assessment draft with your board members: Ask board members for their feedback on the proposed assessment. Is there anything you may have missed? Give them a chance to buy into the structure of the self-assessment.
  5. Set up a simple digital form and share the link: Create an online form using survey software like Google Forms. Distribute the link and provide a reasonable deadline for completion, or carve out time to complete it during your next meeting.
  6. Analyze and share the feedback: Assess the feedback internally or work with a consultant during this final step. Share and discuss the feedback received with members at your next meeting.

Pro tip: Make sure that your self-assessment takes no longer than 15-20 minutes to complete. You want people to invest a reasonable amount of time during the process, and ensure you get accurate information and can act on it accordingly.


What to Do After a Board Self-Assessment

Conducting a board self-assessment is futile if you’re not using the information at your disposal to take meaningful action and correct the problems voiced by your board.

Once you’ve shared and discussed the results of the self-assessment at your next board meeting, identify patterns or trends in the feedback you’ve received. This may highlight a bigger underlying issue that isn’t being addressed.

David Rhode Quote: "In my experience, I’ve found that many organizations utilize a Board Governance Committee to manage self-assessments. However, this may also be an opportunity to engage an external consultant, should your organization require additional support."

Ask your board what they feel should be addressed first. Then, collectively set the agenda and order of priority. Have regular check-ins during board meetings to measure progress and provide updates.


Sample Self-Assessment Questions

Your self-assessment should include closed-ended questions with a “strongly agree to strongly disagree” scale to benchmark performance in key areas over time. You should also include open-ended questions to help board members identify opportunities and challenges from their own perspectives.

Examples of open-ended questions:

  1. What is the one area where our board could improve to be more effective?
  2. Where do you think our board should be spending more time and attention?
  3. How can committees function more effectively?

Examples of closed-ended questions/statements with a scale from strongly agree to strongly disagree:

  1. Board meetings provide sufficient opportunity for strategic thinking and open discussion
  2. The board ensures that the organization has sufficient financial resources and controls to fulfill its mission
  3. Our board provides meaningful strategic leadership

Closing Thoughts

While it may be scary to turn the lens on yourself, it’s important to remember that knowledge is power, and leadership requires reflection.

There’s always going to be positive and negative feedback. But I encourage you to view self-assessments as a valuable tool for the growth of your board and organization.

Speaking of growth, Donorbox provides all the user-friendly fundraising features needed to take your nonprofit’s fundraising efforts to the next level.


FAQs About Nonprofit Board Assessments


1. What is a nonprofit board self-assessment?

A board self-assessment is a vehicle that gives board members a voice and opportunity to express how they feel about being a board member and identify areas for improvement. Self-assessments should be done anonymously for better engagement and honest feedback.


2. How often should I conduct a board assessment?

Board self-assessments should be conducted regularly, preferably once a year. Depending on the terms of your board, you may conduct an assessment annually or every two to three years. Regular self-assessments ensure you address challenges proactively.

In 2005, David Rhode founded, led and scaled Pitch In For Baseball and Softball, a nonprofit organization that increased access to baseball and softball for children in under-resourced communities through the donation of equipment and uniforms.


After leaving Pitch In For Baseball and Softball in 2019, David founded Dot Dot Org, a nonprofit consulting firm focusing on CEO mentoring. David teaches Nonprofit Branding and Nonprofit Consulting at the University of Pennsylvania. He is also the Deputy Director at PennPAC, an organization that mobilizes pro bono teams of University of Pennsylvania alumni as consultants to strengthen the nonprofit sector.


He is the Axiom Business Book Awards Gold Medal winner for “Passion Isn’t Enough: A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Leaders”, released in November 2024. He and his family now live in New York City.

  • linkedin
  • url
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.
❤ Join the fundraising movement!
Subscribe to our e-newsletter to receive the latest blogs, news, and more in your inbox.

Take your donor experience to the next level!
Join the 100,000+ nonprofits already raising funds online.